![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
![]() | ![]() |
|
|
||
Table of Contents1. Introduction. 3. Table 2 - Olmstead Lawsuits. 5. References. 7. Download PDF of Plan table. |
|
Pennsylvania Olmstead and Olmstead Related Cases, 2009May 2009The Center for PAS has tracked 15 Olmstead related case(s) in Pennsylvania. This information is extracted from the "Olmstead and Olmstead-Related Lawsuits" table in the "Introduction to Olmstead Lawsuits and Olmstead Plans" report published on the center for PAS website. Easley v. Snider*Date filed: 1991 Case status: Closed (Sep 1994) Primary Target group: HCBSc Case Type (Olmstead e or Related f): Related Reference (on the Olmstead & Olmstead-related Lawsuits table) : PA119 21 Case Summary & Links to Further Detailsiii: Summary Case regarding 2 individuals, one with TBI, one with multiple sclerosis & mental illness. Both were denied access to the state attendant care program as they cannot hire/supervise attendants or manage legal/financial affairs. Nelson v. Snider*Date filed: n/a Case status: Closed (1994) Primary Target group: MR/DDa Case Type (Olmstead e or Related f): Related Reference (on the Olmstead & Olmstead-related Lawsuits table) : PA211 Case Summary & Links to Further Detailsiii: Summary This successful case is lauded11 (along with Richard C. v. Houstoun, PA9) as a key influence in the development of deinstitutionalization efforts in Pennsylvania. Helen L v. Dedario*Date filed: n/a Case status: Closed (Feb 19957) Primary Target group: Mental Illness Case Type (Olmstead e or Related f): Related Reference (on the Olmstead & Olmstead-related Lawsuits table) : PA33 Case Summary & Links to Further Detailsiii: Summary The plaintiff was confined to a nursing facility even though it was determined that she could live in the community with PAS510. Greist v. Norristown State HospitalDate filed: 1996 Case status: Closed (1997) Primary Target group: Mental Illness Case Type (Olmstead e or Related f): Related Reference (on the Olmstead & Olmstead-related Lawsuits table) : PA42 13 Case Summary & Links to Further Detailsiii: Summary Case regarding individual found not guilty of murder by reason of insanity & committed to state hospital. Plaintiff sued the hospital for extending his commitment & not treating his dyslexia in a more integrated setting. Charles Q v. Houstoun*Date filed: 1996 Case status: Closed (1997) Primary Target group: MR/DDa & Mental Illness Case Type (Olmstead e or Related f): Related Reference (on the Olmstead & Olmstead-related Lawsuits table) : PA53 Case Summary & Links to Further Detailsiii: Summary In this class action, the court ruled favorably for patients in a state psychiatric hospital who had a dual diagnosis & were seeking treatment in the community.10 Kathleen S v. Dept of Public Welfare*Date filed: 1998 Case status: Closed Primary Target group: Mental Illness Case Type (Olmstead e or Related f): Olmstead Reference (on the Olmstead & Olmstead-related Lawsuits table) : PA62 Case Summary & Links to Further Detailsiii: Summary Case regarding people living in the state hospital despite being assessed as eligible for community placement. Elizabeth M et al v. HoustounDate filed: 1999 Case status: Closed Primary Target group: HCBSc Case Type (Olmstead e or Related f): Related Reference (on the Olmstead & Olmstead-related Lawsuits table) : PA73 Case Summary & Links to Further Detailsiii: Summary Class action regarding waitlists (filed by the Disability Law Center). Gross v. HoustounDate filed: 1999 Case status: Closed Primary Target group: HCBSc Case Type (Olmstead e or Related f): Related Reference (on the Olmstead & Olmstead-related Lawsuits table) : PA83 Case Summary & Links to Further Detailsiii: Summary Case regarding waitlists (filed by the Disability Law Center). Richard C. v. HoustounDate filed: 1989 Case status: Closed (Jul 2000) Primary Target group: MR/DDa Case Type (Olmstead e or Related f): Olmstead Reference (on the Olmstead & Olmstead-related Lawsuits table) : PA92 21 Case Summary & Links to Further Detailsiii: Summary Lawsuit by families of people with DD who were to be moved out of a facility that was to be closed. PA P&A; v. Dept of Public Welfare et alDate filed: Sep. 2000 Case status: Closed (Dec 2005) Primary Target group: Mental illness Case Type (Olmstead e or Related f): Olmstead Reference (on the Olmstead & Olmstead-related Lawsuits table) : PA103 23 Case Summary & Links to Further Detailsiii: Summary Case regarding residents of a state nursing facility for seniors. Plaintiffs sought to remove eligible persons from the institutions into HCBS settings. Delong et al vs. HoustounDate filed: Oct. 2000 Case status: Closed (Oct 2002) Primary Target group: MR/DDa Case Type (Olmstead e or Related f): Related Reference (on the Olmstead & Olmstead-related Lawsuits table) : PA112 3 Case Summary & Links to Further Detailsiii: Summary Class action about a limit on the number of individuals served through the Person/Family-directed Supports waiver. Frederick L et al v. Dept of Public Welfare et al.*Date filed: 20012 Case status: Closed38 Primary Target group: Mental illness8 Case Type (Olmstead e or Related f): Olmstead Reference (on the Olmstead & Olmstead-related Lawsuits table) : PA123 23 Case Summary & Links to Further Detailsiii: Summary Class action regarding plaintiffs institutionalized in state hospital despite recommendation for community placement. Network for Quality MR Services in PA v. Dept of Public WelfareDate filed: Mar. 2002 Case status: Closed (Jul 2003) Primary Target group: MR/DDa Case Type (Olmstead e or Related f): Related Reference (on the Olmstead & Olmstead-related Lawsuits table) : PA133 Case Summary & Links to Further Detailsiii: Summary Case brought by a coalition of agencies providing services to individuals in ICF/MR &/or the HCBS waiver program for people with MR/DD, which asks the court to order that direct care staff costs are reimbursed & updated. Sabree et al v. Richman*Date filed: May. 2002 Case status: Closed (Sep 2005) Primary Target group: MR/DDa Case Type (Olmstead e or Related f): Related Reference (on the Olmstead & Olmstead-related Lawsuits table) : PA142 3 Case Summary & Links to Further Detailsiii: Summary Plaintiffs are waitlisted for ICF/MR services & filed this case in response to a proposed reduction of funds for reducing the community services wait list. Alexander v RendellDate filed: Jan, 2006 Case status: Closed (Jan 2009) Primary Target group: MR/DDa Case Type (Olmstead e or Related f): Olmstead Reference (on the Olmstead & Olmstead-related Lawsuits table) : PA15 Case Summary & Links to Further Detailsiii: Summary Plaintiffs were resident of ICF/MR which the state wants to close. Plaintiffs contend that moving them to another ICF/MR or to a HCBS setting would violate Olmstead's 'most integrated setting' rule.
|